Guilt That Punishes and Guilt That Repairs: Cal and Tom in East of Eden
There is a fundamental difference between feeling guilty and being able to take responsibility for what we have done.
Sometimes guilt allows us to recognise that we have hurt someone, care about the impact of our actions, and try to make amends. At other times, however, it becomes something much more cruel: an inner voice that accuses us, punishes us, and convinces us that we are, at our core, bad or unworthy.
This distinction can be explored particularly well through two characters in John Steinbeck’s novel East of Eden: Tom Hamilton and Cal Trask.
Although their stories are different, both characters are confronted with guilt. The ways in which they respond to it offer a useful way of understanding two forms of psychic functioning that psychoanalytic theory associates with persecutory guilt and depressive guilt.
When Guilt Becomes Punishment
Tom Hamilton is one of Samuel Hamilton’s sons. He is a sensitive, hardworking character who is deeply attached to his family.
After his father’s death, Tom remains close to his sister Dessie. When she becomes ill, he tries to care for her and gives her a remedy that he believes will help. Unaware of the seriousness of her condition, he gives her something that worsens her situation. Dessie dies.
Tom cannot bear the thought that he may have contributed to her death.
What matters is that Tom never intended to hurt her. His intention was precisely the opposite: he wanted to help. Yet his experience of what happened becomes dominated by a much more absolute belief:
“I have done something terrible” becomes “I am terrible.”
Tom cannot distinguish between having made a mistake and being a bad person. Guilt ceases to be a signal that allows him to acknowledge harm and becomes a condemnation of his entire self.
Eventually, unable to forgive himself, Tom dies by suicide.
His story can help us understand persecutory guilt: a form of guilt in which a person feels pursued by an internal authority that accuses and punishes them. There is little room for ambiguity, circumstances, or the possibility of reparation. Guilt does not simply say, “You have done something you regret,” but rather, “You are guilty, and you deserve to be punished.”
In its more intense forms, this kind of guilt can be devastating.
It may emerge, for example, after an argument with a partner, when someone thinks they have been too cold or selfish and quickly moves from “Perhaps I hurt them” to “I am a horrible person.” It may arise when a parent makes a mistake and feels that this proves they should never have had children. It can also appear when someone sets a boundary and, instead of considering whether that boundary was necessary, becomes trapped in the feeling that they have been selfish or cruel.
Persecutory guilt leaves little room for thought.
It punishes before it understands.
Guilt That Can Lead to Reparation
Cal Trask represents another possibility.
Cal is also troubled by guilt. He has hurt people he loves and, at certain moments, feels that there is something fundamentally wrong with him that he cannot change.
But towards the end of the novel, a different possibility begins to emerge.
After Aron’s death, Cal feels responsible. He believes he has destroyed his brother and that his father will never be able to love him. Guilt could lead him, as it does Tom, towards punishment and self-destruction.
However, Lee—the character who throughout the novel serves as a figure of reflection and thought—introduces a fundamental idea through his study of Genesis: timshel, often translated as “thou mayest” or “you may.”
It does not mean that a person can do anything without consequences.
It means something deeper: what we have done does not entirely determine what we do next.
Cal cannot undo the harm he has caused. Nor can he bring his brother back to life. But he can decide what to do with his guilt.
Here lies the difference between guilt that persecutes and guilt that can be worked through.
Depressive Guilt: “I Have Caused Harm. What Can I Do Now?”
In the psychoanalytic tradition, Melanie Klein described the depressive position as a developmental achievement through which the child begins to recognise that the same person they love can also be the object of their aggressive feelings.
This involves tolerating something deeply difficult: ambivalence.
We can love someone and feel angry with them. We can need them and, at the same time, want distance from them. We can hurt someone without intending to destroy them. We can make mistakes and still remain worthy of love.
Depressive guilt emerges when we can acknowledge the harm we have caused without having to destroy ourselves for having caused it.
For this reason, it has a reparative dimension.
It does not say:
“I am bad, and I deserve to suffer.”
It says something closer to:
“I have done something I regret. I have caused harm. What can I do about it now?”
The difference is enormous.
Depressive guilt allows us to keep the other person in mind. We can care about how they have felt, acknowledge our responsibility, and try to make amends. At the same time, we can continue to see ourselves as complex people, capable of making mistakes and doing good things.
In this sense, Cal must learn to live with responsibility without turning it into a final verdict on who he is.
Tom and Cal: Two Responses to Guilt
The difference between them can be summarised as follows:
Tom cannot survive his guilt because he turns it into a condemnation of himself.
Cal has the possibility of surviving his guilt because he begins to discover that he can choose what to do next.
This does not mean that Cal stops feeling guilty or that his actions no longer have consequences. On the contrary, the possibility of reparation only emerges when we are able to acknowledge our responsibility.
But responsibility and punishment are not the same thing.
Responsibility turns towards the other person.
Punishment turns against the self.
The first asks:
“What have I done, and how can I repair the harm?”
The second asks:
“What punishment do I deserve for having done this?”
When guilt becomes organised around this second question, it can develop into a cycle that is extremely difficult to break.
Guilt in Everyday Life
We do not need to have experienced a tragedy like the one in Steinbeck’s novel to recognise this distinction.
Guilt can arise in much more ordinary situations:
- After saying no.
- After setting a boundary.
- When prioritising our own needs.
- When disappointing someone.
- After an argument.
- When feeling that we are not doing enough for our children, partner, family, or work.
Sometimes the intensity of our guilt is disproportionate to what we have actually done.
We may apologise for something that did not require an apology. We may feel responsible for emotions that belong to someone else. We may remain in situations that hurt us because saying no triggers an unbearable sense of selfishness.
In these cases, perhaps the most useful question is not simply “Do I have a reason to feel guilty?” but rather:
“What kind of guilt am I experiencing?”
Am I acknowledging something I have actually done and thinking about how to make amends?
Or am I being pursued by an inner voice that needs to find me guilty?
Learning to Live with Ambivalence
An important part of psychotherapy involves developing the capacity to tolerate this complexity.
We do not need to become perfect people in order to free ourselves from persecutory guilt.
We need to accept that we are capable of causing harm and, at the same time, capable of loving.
That we can make mistakes without allowing those mistakes to define our identity.
That we can disappoint someone without necessarily being selfish.
That we can set boundaries and still be caring people.
And that making amends does not always mean getting the other person to stop feeling angry or sad. Sometimes it means acknowledging our part, apologising when appropriate, and accepting that we cannot entirely control how the other person responds.
Depressive guilt, in this sense, does not mean the absence of suffering. It represents a different way of relating to it.
Its purpose is not to punish us for having caused harm, but to help us acknowledge what we have done and consider what we can do now.
Perhaps this is also one of the most hopeful ideas in East of Eden: we cannot change everything we have done, or everything that has happened to us. But we can retain some capacity to choose how we respond.
Thou mayest.
And sometimes, the beginning of reparation lies precisely in no longer asking how much we should punish ourselves, and beginning to ask what we can do differently.
Sessions available in Madrid or online.